[VISUAL] The diagram above represents a particle in aqueous solution. Which of the following stateme — Bonding Chemistry Question
Question
[VISUAL]
The diagram above represents a particle in aqueous solution. Which of the following statements about the particle is correct?
The particle must be a cation because the negative end of each water molecule is pointed toward it.
The particle must be an anion because the positive end of each water molecule is pointed toward it.
The charge of the particle cannot be determined because water molecules have no net charge.
The charge of the particle cannot be determined because the water molecules are arranged symmetrically and their partial charges cancel.
💡 Solution & Explanation
STEPS:
1. Understand the polarity and dipole of water:
A water molecule () is a highly polar molecule due to the large difference in electronegativity between the oxygen atom and the hydrogen atoms. This causes an uneven distribution of charge, resulting in a permanent molecular dipole. The highly electronegative oxygen atom pulls electron density toward itself, acquiring a partial negative charge (), while the hydrogen atoms are electron-deficient and acquire a partial positive charge (). The positive end of this permanent dipole is centered between the two hydrogen atoms.
2. Examine the orientation of the water molecules in the diagram:
In the particulate representation of the solvation shell:
* The water molecules are represented with their two smaller, unshaded hydrogen spheres pointing directly toward the central solute particle.
* The larger, shaded oxygen sphere of each water molecule is directed away from the central particle.
3. Apply the principles of electrostatic attraction (Coulomb's Law):
When an ionic solute dissolves in water, it forms ion-dipole intermolecular attractions with the surrounding solvent molecules. Because opposite charges attract, a charged solute particle will orient the oppositely charged end of the solvent's dipole toward itself.
4. Determine the charge of the central particle:
Since the partially positive hydrogen ends () of the water molecules are pointing directly at the central particle, the central particle must have a negative charge to attract them. An ion with a net negative charge is called an anion. Therefore, the particle must be an anion because the positive end of each water molecule is pointed toward it, which corresponds to Option B.
*
WHY_OTHERS_WRONG:
- Option A is incorrect: The negative end of water's permanent dipole is centered on the oxygen atom (the larger, shaded sphere). In the diagram, the oxygen atoms are pointed away from the central particle, not toward it. If the central particle were a cation, the water molecules would reorient themselves so that their negative oxygen ends faced inward to maximize electrostatic attraction.
- Option C is incorrect: While it is true that water molecules are overall neutral and have no net charge, they possess a highly uneven internal charge distribution (a permanent dipole). This asymmetric distribution means they readily align their positive or negative ends around a solute, allowing us to easily determine the central particle's charge based on which end points inward.
- Option D is incorrect: Due to random molecular motion, the partial charges of the water molecules in the system do not simply cancel out to prevent a determination. Regardless of symmetry, the uniform orientation of the positive dipole ends pointing toward the center is direct visual proof that the central particle is negatively charged.