[VISUAL] The Lewis electron-dot diagrams of the HClO3 molecule and the HClO2 molecule are shown abov — Acids and Bases Chemistry Question
Question
[VISUAL]
The Lewis electron-dot diagrams of the HClO3 molecule and the HClO2 molecule are shown above at the left and right, respectively. Which of the following statements identifies the stronger acid and correctly identifies a factor that contributes to its being the stronger acid?
HClO3(aq) is the stronger acid because its molecules experience stronger London dispersion forces.
HClO3(aq) is the stronger acid because the additional electronegative oxygen atom on the chlorine atom stabilizes the conjugate base.
HClO2(aq) is the stronger acid because its molecules experience weaker London dispersion forces.
HClO2(aq) is the stronger acid because the lone pairs of electrons on the chlorine atom stabilize the conjugate base.
💡 Solution & Explanation
STEPS:
1. Understand what determines acid strength in oxoacids: The strength of an oxoacid is determined by how easily the acidic hydrogen ion () can be donated. This is governed by two key factors: the polarity of the polar covalent bond (making it easier to break) and the stability of the resulting conjugate base after deprotonation.
2. Compare the chemical formulas and structures of the two acids: The two acids under comparison are chloric acid () and chlorous acid (). Their corresponding conjugate bases are the chlorate anion () and the chlorite anion (), respectively.
3. Analyze the role of additional electronegative oxygen atoms: Oxygen is a highly electronegative element. In , there is an additional electronegative oxygen atom bonded to the central chlorine atom compared to .
4. Evaluate the inductive effect and charge delocalization:
* This additional oxygen atom pulls electron density away from the central chlorine atom and the bond via the inductive effect, which highly polarizes the bond and makes the proton much easier to release.
* Furthermore, when the acid dissociates, the negative charge on the resulting conjugate base () can be delocalized (spread out) over a larger number of highly electronegative oxygen atoms. Delocalizing the negative charge increases the thermodynamic stability of the conjugate base.
5. Conclude which acid is stronger: Because a more stable conjugate base corresponds to a stronger parent acid, is the stronger acid because the additional electronegative oxygen atom stabilizes the conjugate base, confirming Option B.
*
WHY_OTHERS_WRONG:
- Option A is incorrect: While it correctly identifies as the stronger acid, it incorrectly attributes this strength to London dispersion forces. London dispersion forces are weak *intermolecular* attractions between separate molecules that govern physical properties like boiling point; they play no role in the chemical process of covalent bond cleavage during acid dissociation.
- Option C is incorrect: This option incorrectly identifies as the stronger acid and further makes the chemically irrelevant claim about London dispersion forces.
- Option D is incorrect: This option incorrectly identifies as the stronger acid. Additionally, the lone pairs on the chlorine atom do not stabilize the conjugate base; rather, having more lone pairs on the central atom concentrates localized negative charge, which makes the conjugate base more reactive (a stronger conjugate base, meaning a weaker parent acid).