🧪 TheChemSolverInternational Chemistry Olympiad
Physical ChemistryIChO

Substance P is synthesized from substances X and Y in a constant-flow reactor which has two feeds foPhysical Chemistry Chemistry Question

Black box

Substance P is synthesized from substances X and Y in a constant-flow reactor which has two feeds for reagent solutions and one outlet for a resulting solution (all solutions are liquid). The operator of the reactor can set flows of the reagents at his will. Due to intensive stirring the concentration of any substance is the same in any part of the reactor. The measured parameters of the working reactor are given in the table below.

11.1.

Using the data above, obtain as much information as possible about this system, e.g. the volume of the reactor, the reaction rate constant, the reaction orders, etc. If you find the reaction orders, propose a mechanism which is consistent with the discovered rate law.
Hint: because the reaction proceeds in a liquid phase, the output volumetric flow is equal to the sum of input volumetric flows.

Model Answer

Since this is a reactor with ideal stirring, the concentrations of substances in the output flow are equal to the concentrations inside the reactor. In a stationary state, the concentrations and quantities of substances in the reactor are constant. Consider the material balance with respect to X, Y and P.
Stationary conditions are:
∆νX,R / ∆t = 0; ∆νY,R / ∆t = 0; ∆νP,R / ∆t = 0, (1)
where ∆νX,R, ∆νY,R, ∆νP,R are the changes of the quantities for the substances X, Y and P in the reactor during time ∆t. The quantity of the substance in the reactor may change due to input flow, chemical reaction, and output flow:
(∆νX,R / ∆t) = (∆νX,R / ∆t)input + (∆νX,R / ∆t)reaction + (∆νX,R / ∆t)output (2)
The same is true for Y and P.
Input flow rates of the substances are
(∆νX,R / ∆t)input = fX cX,I ; (∆νY,R / ∆t)input = fY cY,I ; (∆νP,R / ∆t)input = 0, (3)
where fX and fY are the input volumetric flows of the solutions of X and Y, cX,I and cY,I – concentrations of X and Y in the respective solutions.
Let the balanced reaction equation be
nX X + nY Y = nP P
where nX, nY and nP are the stoichiometric coefficients for the corresponding substances.
Due to a chemical reaction the quantities of the substances in the reactor change with the rates
(∆νX,R / ∆t)reaction = - nX r VR; (∆νY,R / ∆t)reaction = - nY r VR; (∆νP,R / ∆t)reaction = nP r VR, (4)
where r – the reaction rate, VR – the reactor volume.
The output flows of the substances are:
(∆νX,R / ∆t)output = - fO cX,R ; (∆νY,R / ∆t)output = - fO cY,R ; (∆νP,R / ∆t)output = - fO cP,R , (5)
where fO is the volumetric output flow, cX,R, cY,R and cP,R – the concentrations of substances X, Y and P in the reactor. Since the process is stationary and the reaction proceeds in the liquid phase, the output volumetric flow equals the sum of input volumetric flows:
fO = fX + fY (6)
Thus the material balance equations (2) considering expressions (1) and (3)-(6) are
∆νX,R / ∆t = fX cX,I - nX r VR - cX,R (fX + fY) = 0
∆νY,R / ∆t = fY cY,I - nY r VR - cY,R (fX + fY) = 0
∆νP,R / ∆t = nP r VR - cP,R (fX + fY) = 0
Hence
nX r VR = fX cX,I - cX,R (fX + fY)
nY r VR = fY cY,I - cY,R (fX + fY)
nP r VR = cP,R (fX + fY)

Exp. no. | nXrVR, mol/s | nYrVR, mol/s | nPrVR, mol/s | nX:nY:nP
1 | 10.02 | 20.04 | 10.02 | 1:2:1
2 | 10.04 | 20.07 | 10.05 | 1:2:1
3 | 15.73 | 31.47 | 15.72 | 1:2:1
4 | 19.68 | 39.34 | 19.68 | 1:2:1

Hence the balanced reaction equation is
X + 2 Y = P

Now consider the rate dependence on concentrations
Exp. no. | cX,R, mol/m3 | cY,R, mol/m3 | cP,R, mol/m3 | r VR, mol/s
1 | 299 | 48.2 | 501 | 10.02
2 | 732 | 30.9 | 335 | 10.04
3 | 8.87 | 351 | 524 | 15.73
4 | 308 | 66.6 | 492 | 19.68

The rate law is r = k cX,R^x cY,R^y cP,R^p
or, after multiplying by reactor volume, r VR = k VR cX,R^x cY,R^y cP,R^p
Take the logarithm of both parts of the equation
ln(rVR) = ln(kVR) + x ln(cX,R) + y ln(cY,R) + p ln(cP,R) (7)

The coefficients in this equation are given in the table below:
Exp. no. | ln cX,R | ln cY,R | ln cP,R | ln (rVR)
1 | 5.70 | 3.88 | 6.22 | 2.30
2 | 6.60 | 3.43 | 5.81 | 2.31
3 | 2.18 | 5.86 | 6.26 | 2.76
4 | 5.73 | 4.20 | 6.20 | 2.98

Solving the system of equations (7) we get:
x = 1.00; y = 2.00; p = 0.01; ln(kVR) = -11.20
Hence the orders of the reaction are one in X, two in Y, and zero in P. The product kVR is:
k VR = exp(-11.20) = 1.37 · 10^-5 m9mol-2s-1.

One of the possible mechanisms that match the obtained rate law is:
X + Y ↔ I (fast)
I + Y → P (slow, rate-determining)

Summarizing, the obtained results are:
♦ the reaction equation: X + 2 Y = P;
♦ the reaction orders: 1, 2, and 0 with respect to X, Y, and P respectively;
♦ the product of the rate constant and reactor volume: k VR = 1.37 · 10^-5 m9⋅mol-2⋅s-1.

💬
Still have doubts about this question?
Practice more questions like this, completely free.

Practice International Chemistry Olympiad questions like this — free

4,000+ questions across AP Chemistry, USNCO, and IChO — all free, no signup required.